Step 1: Export Your Links From Google Search Console
Checking backlinks isn't just for audits. The three most common reasons are confirming a paid or earned placement actually went live, spotting risky links before they cause problems, and working out what's helping a competitor who outranks you.
Start with Google Search Console. Open the Links report (left menu, near the bottom) and look at Top linking sites and Top linked pages. Use Export external links (top right) and choose More sample links or Latest links to download a spreadsheet. It won't give you authority scores, but it's the closest thing to what Google itself has found.
Google Analytics won't show you your backlinks directly. GA4 tracks referral traffic (visits arriving through a link), which is useful for seeing which links actually send visitors, but it doesn't list the links themselves. For that you need Search Console or a backlink tool.
Step 2: Add a Free Backlink Checker
Search Console only covers your own site. Free tiers of Ahrefs' Backlink Checker, Moz Link Explorer and Ubersuggest show a limited sample (usually the strongest 100 or so links) with authority metrics, which is enough to sanity-check a new placement or look at a competitor without a subscription. For deeper work, the paid tools compare like this:
Ahrefs
- Large link index
- DR (Domain Rating) metric
- Strong for competitor gap analysis
- Historical backlink data
Semrush
- Toxic-link flags
- Combined with keyword data
- Disavow-file workflow
- Backlink Gap tool
Google Search Console
- Free, always
- Google's own view of your links
- No competitor data
- No authority metrics
Step 3: Group Links by Referring Domain
Paste your exports into one sheet and remove duplicates. Then count referring domains, not total backlinks: one site can link to you hundreds of times from a sidebar or footer, and that counts as one relationship. A growing number of unique referring domains is the clearest sign a link profile is healthy.
Step 4: Check Relevance and Anchor Text
For each referring domain, ask two questions. Is the site about something related to your business, and does it have real visitors of its own? And what words does the link use? A natural profile is mostly your brand name, your URL and generic phrases (“this guide”, “their website”), with only a small share of exact keyword anchors like “cheap plumber Dallas”.
Step 5: Find Risky Patterns
Look for patterns rather than single bad links: many links from unrelated sites that exist only to sell posts, sudden spikes of links you didn't build, lots of exact-match anchors, sitewide footer links, and links from obvious networks. Google mostly ignores spammy links on its own; a disavow file is only worth considering for links you or a past agency built that break Google's spam policies, or after a manual action in Search Console.
Step 6: Find Gaps Against Competitors
Run a competitor's domain through Ahrefs' Site Explorer or Semrush's Backlink Analytics and focus on three things:
- Their referring domains, not total backlinks. This is the honest measure of how many sites vouch for them.
- Sites that link to two or more competitors but not to you. These are your most realistic outreach targets.
- Which of their pages attract the most links. Usually a data study, a free tool or a useful resource, not the homepage. That tells you what kind of content earns links in your niche.
This kind of backlink competitive analysis is the first step in most of the campaigns we run: you can't outbuild a competitor's link profile without knowing where it came from.
Backlink Analysis Template
Record what you find in one sheet with these columns: referring domain, linking page, target page, anchor text, link type (follow, nofollow, sponsored, ugc), first seen, relevant?, real traffic?, exact-match anchor?, notes and action (keep, monitor, remove, disavow). Download the backlink analysis template (CSV) and open it in Google Sheets or Excel.